Author Topic: Feature to delete previous IPTC content  (Read 4079 times)

Offline heavymeister

  • Member
  • **
  • Posts: 92
    • View Profile
Feature to delete previous IPTC content
« on: October 06, 2010, 06:28:16 AM »
We receive photos from different photographer who IPTC'ed their photos with all kind of applications and we use PM to correct these IPTC records if they are not meeting our standards. Then we pass photos on to clients using different asset management systems or tools and some of these show other IPTC records than what we have added. These systems read IPTC records that were there in the first place, depending on what application the photographer used to IPTC the file. I took a closer look at these photos with ExifTool and foud that there are sometimes up to three different IPTC records stored with the file.

As I can't order neither photographer nor client what software to use to handle their photos I would like to be able to control all IPTC records with PM. So I ask for a feature in PM that can delete all previous IPTC records (and maybe even the EXIF description field) and adds just the IPTC record that is typed in the IPTC apply pane.

Anyone else in favour of that feature? 

HM

Offline Kirk Baker

  • Senior Software Engineer
  • Camera Bits Staff
  • Superhero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 25020
    • View Profile
    • Camera Bits, Inc.
Re: Feature to delete previous IPTC content
« Reply #1 on: October 06, 2010, 07:33:34 AM »
We receive photos from different photographer who IPTC'ed their photos with all kind of applications and we use PM to correct these IPTC records if they are not meeting our standards. Then we pass photos on to clients using different asset management systems or tools and some of these show other IPTC records than what we have added. These systems read IPTC records that were there in the first place, depending on what application the photographer used to IPTC the file. I took a closer look at these photos with ExifTool and foud that there are sometimes up to three different IPTC records stored with the file.

As I can't order neither photographer nor client what software to use to handle their photos I would like to be able to control all IPTC records with PM. So I ask for a feature in PM that can delete all previous IPTC records (and maybe even the EXIF description field) and adds just the IPTC record that is typed in the IPTC apply pane.

Have you tried the Delete Metadata command on the Tools menu?  Does it not meet your needs?

-Kirk

Offline heavymeister

  • Member
  • **
  • Posts: 92
    • View Profile
Re: Feature to delete previous IPTC content
« Reply #2 on: October 06, 2010, 01:18:20 PM »
The delete metadata erases also the current record that I would like to keep (the one that I see on the pane). I need to keep the info from the caption for each file since only the photographer knows what describes the content of the photo. PM reads out and shows the correct IPTC/XMP data (except when some older Fotostation versions have been used for the initial IPTC writing).
Thus the requested feature should leave the current record untouched and just delete all previous IPTC records, so that I get a clean file according IPTC/XMP standard, that can be interpreted by all applications that follow these standards.
Most users might have not encountered problems with previous IPTC records, since they are not visible in PM. I was not aware of it too until I was shown screenshots of the IPTC/XMP readout of other applications, such as image bank databases and in some cases Adobe InDesign.
I have performed extensive tests with all sorts of applications regarding IPTC/XMP handling and came to the conclusion that PM is the only tool that handles IPTC/XMP correctly according standard. Not even the Adobe products keep a stringent interpretation of IPTC/XMP. And depending on the software that was used to write the IPTC record initially you get different results in the end even if PM was used as a second IPTC writer when updating the file.
Maybe it might even help to set PM by default to delete all existing (invisible) previous IPTC records and just keep the last one and update this to IPTC/XMP standard.